I am very interested in what you could call the search for the ‘Historical Jesus’- in other words what does empirical historical or archaeological evidence show we definitely know about Jesus and his life, compared with what we know and believe through our faith.
Not too long ago a fairly naïve and uninformed writer questioned whether Jesus ever existed, and in the most recent surveys carried out by 'You Gov' and the Church of England around 25% of people in England think Jesus was a fictional, rather than historical figure, which is rather scary.
So, what do we really know and how do we respond to people who question Jesus’ very existence?
Well, historians and archaeologists will generally talk about what they call the ‘Historian’s Creed’, that is to say that they can be sure there is strong corroborative evidence to say the following is true: a) Jesus lived in 1st century Palestine, b) He preached and healed amongst people, c) He gathered followers but also enemies, d) He was executed on the orders of Pontius Pilate and e) within a short period of his death churches and followers of Jesus emerged.
Beyond that, theologians will say that the other things we know happened as recorded in the Gospels- e.g., the Virgin birth, the slaughter of innocents, the feeding of the 5000, the Resurrection etc may have happened but they cannot prove it to a high degree of satisfaction. That is not their fault because they have to be able to say that because for example they found this testimony or that object, then that proves something happened. They are also among the first to make it clear that it would be unreasonable to expect to find much empirical evidence about people living in the 1st century-but clear evidence of Jesus and the impact he had is there.
For me however, the most powerful evidence is that there was an incredible ‘energy’ following Jesus’ crucifixion that demonstrates something extraordinary took place, people started to follow him, churches were set up to worship and praise Him. People -the Christian martyrs- chose to die rather than deny Jesus’ divinity-they knew the Truth and in short, things changed for ever.
One of the more interesting snippets of news recently was the well-respected study undertaken by the news agency Reuters which concluded that we are gradually becoming a nation of ‘news avoiders’. It revealed that 46% of us avoid reading, seeing, or hearing the news, and it is a worldwide trend too.
When asked why this was, people referred to the news bringing down their mood, creating a feeling of powerlessness over events, and that it led to arguments that they would rather avoid. One person perhaps summed up the mood when they said “ (the news can) trigger my anxiety and things can have a negative impact on my day.”
I suspect a lot of us would recognise that. Part of the issue is that generally speaking the news tends to be typically negative -it generally does not report positive events but instead focuses on what we might call the ‘doom and gloom’. In recent weeks the headlines have been about death of the people in the Titan submersible, reports of parents being jailed for killing their children, people attacked in terrorist atrocities, high inflation, strikes, the war in the Ukraine and even a Bishop questioning how ‘safe’ the Church of England is- the list goes on …
It is very understandable why people switch off or avoid the news- in terms of our mental health we are impacted by our environment, we react to what we are told or experience, and anything that can reduce our anxiousness is of course welcome.
What I have found that works well is to avoid news either first or last thing in the day – otherwise you can either start the day negatively or your sleep suffers if you take in bad news. It is better to take news in sometime in between.
As Christians though, avoidance of the news does come with its own challenges because of the belief that we should be ‘in the world but not of it’- that really comes from John 17:11 where before Jesus is arrested he says a prayer for his disciples:
“I will remain the world no longer, but they are still in the world, and I am coming to you. Holy Father, protect them by the power of your name you gave me, so that they may be one as we are one”.
If we avoid the news, avoid the reality of this world, we lose the ability of fellowship with the other travellers on our journey for we are Christ’s Ambassadors. That means we need to love and serve the people of this world, but without what could be termed ‘entanglement’-this means we bring the ‘salt and light’ to the world, but to do that we must not isolate ourselves from it. That can be very difficult especially with a world that may feel alien to many of us.
I feel that as fellow believers that means we need to be aware of and engage in the world, but we need to do it carefully and selectively. Be aware what bad news can do to us but also take on board what is happening to allow us to give Jesus’ alternative. It is a careful path to tread so choose wisely!
In all of the rather distasteful blanket wall-to-wall coverage over the Phillip Scholfield and ‘This Morning’ TV saga I was struck by the number of people trying to understand it, although they may not have realised it, through the lens of Christian thought and belief. For example, Scholfield’s ‘This Morning’ colleague Alison Hammond upset by the revelations, broke down saying:
“..my mum always said ‘use your Bible as the Sat Nav for your life’, and in the Bible it says ‘he without sin cast the first stone’…”
Elsewhere in the forensic interview that the BBC’s Amol Rajan held with Scholfield he asked him:
“..they say ‘the truth sets you free,’ so for all the stress you’ve been living with, do you feel slightly liberated by speaking out?…”
Now both of these sayings come from the same part of the gospels, namely John 8, and start (surprise, surprise) regarding the matter of adultery. It is worth exploring them for the light they bring on the situation and the very nature of sin, forgiveness and freedom.
In John 8:7, the background is that Jesus was teaching people in the temple courts when Pharisees brough to him a woman who had been caught in adultery, they point out that the Law of Moses requires them to stone her as a punishment, and they tried to set a trap for Jesus by asking him what he thinks they should do.
Jesus is said to have “..bent down and started to write on the ground with his finger…” before saying to the group “He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her”. We don’t know what it was Jesus wrote on the ground, but the effect of his statement was absolute- they were convicted by their conscience and left the scene. Talking to the adulterous woman, Jesus said simply “Woman, where are those thine accusers? Hath no man condemned thee?...Neither do I condemn thee: go, and sin no more”.
The point Jesus was making is who are we to judge? We are all sinners and have we the right to condemn? As Christians we are called to be kind, compassionate and offer graceful love to each and every one, forgiving those just as Christ God has forgiven us. It was something He referred to in Matthew 7:1-3 when he said “Why do you look at the speck of sawdust in your brother’s eye and pay no attention to the plank in your own eye?”. In other words, we should practice what we preach before criticising others.
Later in John 8:31-38, after the incident with the adulterous woman, people questioned who Jesus actually was. Jesus explained he was not of this world but was carrying out the wishes of the Father-God. People did not understand Him but to those who did, Jesus said “ if you continue in my word then you are my disciples indeed, and you shall know the truth and the truth shall make you free”.
That statement ‘The truth shall make you free’ is of course one of the most famous ever spoken and not surprisingly a considerable number of organisations have it as their motto from the CIA to numerous universities. Although Jesus was talking about the truth in the sense that by believing in Him you will be free from the slavery of sin, it has another practical meaning that by living a lie- presenting yourself as someone who you are not – is a sin to the spirit, and you pay a heavy price for that.
Shakespeare got it right when in ‘Hamlet’, Polonius gives advice to his son: “…this above all: to thine own self be true, and it must follow, as the night the day, thou canst not then be false to any man…”.
A lesson from this tragic affair may be to honour your pledges to people, to turn away from the sin of temptation, and above all live a life of freedom from sin- the one Truth can give you that....
One of the things that you experience when you read the New Testament, are the numerous occasions when Jesus’ disciples show their doubt about His mission, teaching and actions. It isn’t just Thomas (John 20:24-29) who is sceptical and needed physical proof to believe, even though they saw Jesus’ amazing powers to heal and other great works, they fairly regularly doubted that he was indeed the Son of God.
In fact, how people reacted to Jesus’ mission tend to fall into three broad categories. There were those who accepted him wholeheartedly- people for example like the demon possessed man who was healed and the Centurion whose faith was such that just the word of Jesus was sufficient to bring back to health his sick servant. Then there were those who opposed him – some Pharisees, King Herod, the Romans and other teachers/experts of the Law because of the threat Jesus posed to them, and of course ultimately it led to them conspiring to kill him. The third group of people are those who neither accepted Jesus wholeheartedly or rejected him but who were unsure or doubted him and who he was- in essence they had a rather agnostic viewpoint.
There are numerous examples of where the disciples fell short in their faith- think of how they responded to Jesus’ teaching of the parable of the Sower, the feeding of the five thousand, Jesus’ repeated statements where he predicted his death, or where Jesus calmed the storm or walked on water. At these times, the disciples’ response, rather than seeing these events as signs and evidence to confirm who He was, was to ask “Who is this?” (Mark 4:41).
They were not alone in their doubts- even John the Baptist was unsure as in Matthew 11:3 he asked of Jesus: “Are you the one who was to come, or should we expect someone else?” Now this is John who personally baptised Jesus and witnessed the descent of the Holy Spirit upon him and declared him the Lamb of God-tey even he doubted!
So how do we deal with doubt? For wisdom I look to the late and great Selwyn Hughes who amongst other achievements set up the Crusade for World Revival (CWR). He once said “Many Christians are afflicted with doubt. Doubt is not the problem; it is how we respond to it that determines whether it will be an obstacle or an opportunity. Don’t repress your doubts but acknowledge them and bring them to Jesus. Face them in the confidence that they can be used as stepping stones to a deeper awareness of God”.
That has to be right – we should not feel guilty if we have doubts, in many senses they are natural, but as Selwyn said, it is more about how we deal with that doubt, that we should shine a light on them and take them to God in prayer.
